5 Essential Steps to Decide Between Covered Calls And Dividend Growth ETFs

Investors looking for steady income often turn to exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that provide regular payouts.

Two common approaches to generating income through ETFs are covered-call ETFs and dividend growth ETFs. 

Covered-call ETFs create income by selling call options on their holdings, while dividend growth ETFs distribute earnings from dividend-paying stocks. 

While both strategies offer cash flow, they differ in terms of growth potential, risk exposure, and tax treatment.

Understanding these differences can help investors determine which approach aligns best with their financial goals and market outlook.

1. Understanding the Difference: Covered Calls vs. Dividend Growth

• Covered-call ETFs generate income by selling call options on their holdings, collecting premiums from buyers. In exchange for this income, they limit their upside potential, as the underlying stocks may be sold at a predetermined price if the options are exercised. 

This strategy provides steady cash flow but can underperform in strong bull markets when stock prices rise sharply.

These funds are often marketed for their high yields, making them attractive to income-focused investors who prioritize consistent payouts over long-term growth.

• Dividend ETFs generate income by investing in dividend-paying stocks. These funds hold shares of companies that regularly distribute a portion of their earnings to shareholders. Unlike covered-call ETFs, dividend ETFs allow for full participation in market growth while still providing income. 

Many of these ETFs focus on companies with strong financials and a history of increasing dividends over time, which can lead to rising income streams.

This makes them a preferred option for long-term investors looking to balance income generation with stock price appreciation.

2. Evaluating Market Performance

Dividend ETFs tend to outperform covered-call ETFs during strong bull markets.

Because they hold dividend-paying stocks without selling options against them, they can experience full price appreciation while continuing to generate income. 

In contrast, covered-call ETFs may lag behind as their option contracts limit the potential for gains when stock prices rise significantly.

This makes dividend ETFs a more attractive option for investors who want to build wealth over time while still receiving passive income.

In flat or slightly bearish markets, covered-call ETFs can be more effective at generating consistent income.

The premiums collected from selling call options provide a steady cash flow, even when stock prices are not increasing. 

This makes them particularly useful for investors who prioritize income stability over capital appreciation.

However, during market downturns, both covered-call ETFs and dividend ETFs can experience losses.

Dividend ETFs may decline in value along with the broader market, while covered-call ETFs may see their income generation reduced if market volatility drops.

3. Assessing Risk Factors

Covered-call ETFs come with specific risks, including limited growth potential due to their options strategy. While they generate regular income, they may underperform in prolonged bull markets, as their ability to participate in stock price increases is capped. 

These funds also tend to have higher expense ratios than traditional dividend ETFs due to the complexity of managing options contracts. Additionally, the income generated from selling options may not fully offset losses in a severe market downturn.

Dividend ETFs also carry risks, primarily related to potential dividend cuts. If a company faces financial difficulties, it may reduce or suspend its dividend, which can impact the ETF’s income. 

Market volatility can also affect dividend ETFs, as their stock prices fluctuate alongside economic conditions.

Some dividend ETFs are concentrated in specific sectors, which may increase risk if those industries underperform.

However, well-diversified dividend ETFs that focus on companies with strong earnings and reliable dividend histories tend to be more resilient over time.

4. Understanding Tax Implications

Tax treatment is an important factor when comparing covered-call ETFs and dividend ETFs. Dividend ETFs primarily distribute qualified dividends, which are taxed at lower long-term capital gains rates.

This makes them a more tax-efficient option for investors in taxable accounts. 

In contrast, covered-call ETFs generate income mainly from selling options, which is taxed as ordinary income at a higher rate.

This tax difference can result in a heavier burden for investors holding covered-call ETFs outside of tax-advantaged accounts.

5. Choosing the Right Strategy for Your Goals

Both covered-call ETFs and dividend ETFs can be effective for generating income, but they cater to different investment goals.

Covered-call ETFs are well-suited for investors who prioritize high, consistent income with lower volatility, particularly in sideways or mildly bullish markets.

However, their growth potential is limited, making them less appealing for long-term wealth accumulation.

Dividend ETFs offer a balance of income and growth, making them a strong choice for investors focused on long-term capital appreciation.

By holding high-quality dividend-paying stocks, these ETFs provide stable income while allowing for full participation in market growth.

Investors who seek both rising income and potential stock price appreciation may find dividend ETFs to be a better fit. 

Understanding the differences and implications between these strategies is crucial for making well-informed investment choices that align with your personal investment strategy.

Are You Ready to Learn How to Successfully Compound Your Investments?

Do you want to learn how to analyze assets that align with your unique risk tolerance and financial goals?

Are you interested in mastering the proven 5-Step Invest Diva Diamond Analysis strategy and the Triple Compounding™ method I use?

Register for your FREE Triple Compounding™ Training HERE and get Kiana’s Triple Compounding™ workbook and personal risk management toolkit for FREE. Both available at no cost to you.

If you enjoyed my blog post about Arm Holdings, you’ll love my post on ‘Riding the AI Wave: Why TSMC Is the Chipmaker to Watch’.

Disclosure: I am not a financial advisor, and this is not financial advice. This information is for educational purposes only. This post about Arm Holdings may contain affiliate links, meaning I get a commission if you decide to make a purchase through my links, at no cost to you. Please see the terms of service page for more information.