PayPal’s Comeback: Is PayPal Stock A Smart Long Term Buy In 2025?

PayPal is making waves again! Not just as a payment processor but as a full-blown commerce platform. After a strong Q1 2025 earnings report, the company has investors asking: is this the start of a long-term comeback? 

Let’s break it down using the IDDA framework — Capital, Intentional, Fundamental, Sentimental, and Technical analysis — to find out if this fintech giant belongs in your portfolio.

IDDA Point 1 & 2: Capital & Intentional

Before investing in PayPal (PYPL), ask yourself:

✅ Does this stock align with your long-term value investing goals?
✅ Are you comfortable with short-term volatility in exchange for long-term potential?
✅ Do you believe in the growth of digital payments, fintech innovation, and commerce platforms?

PayPal can be considered a deep value stock, meaning it is trading far below what many believe it’s truly worth, not because the company is failing, but because the market hasn’t fully recognized its transformation. Even with rising revenue, solid profits, and billions spent on buying back its own shares, the stock is still priced like it was back in 2017.

The company just posted strong Q1 2025 results and is evolving from a payment processor into a full-scale commerce ecosystem. With over 436 million active accounts, growing Venmo adoption, and plans to leverage AI and ads, PayPal is positioning itself for long-term relevance.

If you believe in PayPal’s ability to modernize, unlock shareholder value, and expand its global footprint, PYPL could be an overlooked gem. 

Don’t know your risk tolerance? Get Kiana Danial’s risk management toolkit for free here.

IDDA Point 3: Fundamentals

PayPal is evolving. Once known simply as a digital payment processor, it’s now working to become a comprehensive commerce platform—positioning itself as a key player in online, in-store, and peer-to-peer transactions.

Under new CEO Alex Chriss, the company is focused on integrating branded checkout, Venmo, PSP (Payment Service Provider) tools, and omnichannel capabilities. The goal? To be seamlessly embedded in every step of the consumer and merchant experience, across both digital and physical spaces.

PayPal is also making bold moves into AI, building out an advertising business, and expanding its footprint in crypto. These initiatives signal a long-term strategy to diversify revenue and stay competitive in a rapidly changing fintech landscape.

On the capital front, PayPal remains committed to share buybacks, having returned over $30 billion to shareholders and repurchased nearly 20% of its outstanding shares since 2014. The company holds $15.8 billion in cash and investments, providing a solid liquidity base. 

🔹Key strategic focuses include:

• Growing Venmo and branded checkout.
• Expanding Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) offerings.
• Rolling out AI-driven commerce tools.
• Improving merchant tools for small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs).

🔹PayPal Financials Q1 2025

• Revenue Growth: Up 9% YoY for Q1
• Total Payment Volume (TPV): Up 8%
• Venmo Revenue: Up 20%
• BNPL Volume: Up 20%
• Operating Expenses: Down to $6.26B from $6.93B in Q4
• Gross Margin: Improved to 42.6% (Q1 2025) from 39% (Q1 2024)
• Net Margin: Increased to 16.5%
• ROE: Strong at 20%
• ROA & ROIC: Still trailing, with room for improvement

🧠 Takeaways: Management is clearly positioning PayPal for long-term, high-margin growth through diversification and platform expansion. Despite lagging margins compared to peers, PayPal is showing clear progress in profitability and cost control, which can be a strong sign for long-term investors.

IDDA Point 4: Sentimental

🟢With Q1 beating expectations and Q2 guidance above analyst consensus, investor confidence is picking up. AI buzz and BNPL success also add a tech-forward narrative that investors love.

⚠️Risks to keep in mind:

• High competition in digital payments (Apple Pay, Stripe, Square).
• Declining take rate or transaction rate could hurt revenue
• Regulatory headwinds in the fintech space
• Cybersecurity threats that could hurt brand trust i.e. fraud, phishing, data breaches

🧠 Takeaway: Sentiment is shifting positively, but PayPal needs to continue executing to maintain this momentum.

Want our top stock picks and analysis every month? Get our monthly newsletter here.

IDDA Point 5: Technical

On the weekly chart, PayPal (PYPL) was in a strong uptrend until July 2021, when it peaked around the $310 level. 

Since then, the price has dropped sharply and entered a period of slow recovery and consolidation. A double top pattern(highlighted by the blue circles) confirms the longer-term bearish trend.

Currently the stock is trading 78% from its 2021 peak

Looking at the daily chart, the stock has been trending downward throughout early 2025. This downtrend is also supported by the double top pattern, which is typically a bearish reversal signal. However, after the Q1 2025 earnings report, the stock has started to climb back up.

Although the Ichimoku Cloud still shows 🔴 bearish signals, like the price being below the cloud and a bearish future cloud, the Tenkan line has now crossed above the Kijun line, a 🟢 bullish crossover often called a “golden cross.” This is an early sign that a potential recovery may be on the horizon.

If the uptrend continues and the price breaks above the Ichimoku Cloud, currently acting as resistance, it would further confirm a bullish trend.

Investors looking to get into PYPL can consider the following buy limit levels:

📌Current market price 67.24 (High Risk – FOMO entry)

📌64.89 (High Risk)

📌60.59 (Medium Risk)

📌56.00 (Low Risk)

Here are the Invest Diva ‘Confidence Compass’ questions to ask yourself before buying at each level:

1. If I buy at this price and the price drops by another 50%, how would I feel? Would I panic, or would I buy more to dollar-cost average at lower prices?

2. If I don’t buy at this price and the market suddenly turns around and starts going up again, will I beat myself up for not having bought at this level?

Remember: Investing is personal, and what is right for me might not be right for you. Always do your own due diligence. You should ONLY invest based on your own risk tolerance and your timeframe for reaching your portfolio goals

Final Thoughts on PayPal

PayPal (PYPL) is no longer just a way to pay online. It’s turning into a full-scale digital commerce platform. After a solid Q1 2025 earnings report, the company is showing signs of a comeback.

With over 436 million users, growing Venmo adoption, and bold moves into AI, crypto, and advertising, PayPal is working to reinvent itself. It’s also buying back billions in stock and holding strong cash reserves.

Despite its progress, PayPal’s stock trades at 2017 levels and is down more than 78% from its 2021 peak, reflecting a significant disconnect between fundamentals and market valuation.

For long-term investors who believe in the future of fintech and digital commerce, PayPal could be a hidden gem with room to grow, despite some risks and competition.

Want to become a self sufficient Triple Compounder who no longer needs to read this blog? 

Attend this free Triple Compounding Training here 👇👇

If you enjoyed my blog post about the ‘PayPal’s Comeback: Is PYPL a Smart Long-Term Buy in 2025?’ , you’ll love my post on ‘Elon Musk Is Back! But Can Tesla Recover After Its Latest Earnings Slump?’

Disclosure: I am not a financial advisor, and this is not financial advice. This information is for educational purposes only. This post about ‘PayPal’s Comeback: Is PYPL a Smart Long-Term Buy in 2025?’ may contain affiliate links, meaning I get a commission if you decide to make a purchase through my links, at no cost to you. Please see the terms of service page for more information.